Let's Talk about the Federal Budget-Part 1

Jim Himes hosted a telephonic town hall last week on the Federal debt, where in typical Himes fashion he supported ..... Wait. What did he support? I think he supported the Simpson-Bowles plan. Maybe. Sort of. Or was it the Gang of Six plan. Maybe. Sort of. Definitely not Paul Ryan's plan. Too radical. Not sure if he had an opinion on the President's budget, which was voted down by the Senate 97-0.

But we did learn some things. For instance, Himes is in favor of eliminating loopholes in the tax code so he can introduce more loopholes in the tax code. Specifically, he wants to get rid of deductions oil and gas companies take on their tax returns so he can replace that with deductions solar and wind energy producers will take on their tax returns. He wants to replace ethanol subsidies with green energy subsidies. Reminds us of The Who line, "Meet the new boss. Same as the old boss."

But the main topic of the call was the Federal deficit, the debt ceiling and the budget. Let's start with some numbers. In (fiscal) 2010 the Federal Government spent $3.456 trillion. The biggest items were $707 billion on Social Security, $693 billion on Defense, $622 billion on Medicaid and other Income Security programs. and $451 billion on Medicare.

The President commissioned a group to study the budget and suggest changes. This group, headed by Alan Simpson and Erksine Bowles published their conclusions late last year. They suggesting growing the Federal budget from $3.456 trillion in 2010 to $5.1 trillion in 2020.

President Obama submitted a budget that suggested increasing Federal spending from $3.456 trillion in 2010 to $5,629 trillion in 2020.

Finally, Congressman Paul Ryan, in April, put forth a plan to increase Federal spending from $3.456 trillion in 2010 to $4.544 trillion in 2020.

In brief:
Paul Ryan spending increase 2010-20 equals 31.5%.
Simpson-Bowles spending increase 2010-20 equals 45.0%
President Obama spending increase 2010-20 equals 62.9%.

For all of these plans, the US would still have a budget deficit in 2020. President Obama's would top $1 trillion.

Some more perspective. The cumulative spending, from 2012-2021, which is the period all of these budget debates are discussing is somewhere around $45 trillion. Simpson-Bowles suggest somewhere around $44 trillion, President Obama around $47 trillion and Paul Ryan around $40 trillion.

The debate on budget cuts are NOT debates on spending cuts; they are debates on cutting the growth of spending. They are debates on cutting proposed budgets. Exactly like the debate we had on the Board of Ed budget where reducing the growth of spending from 8% to 4% was characterized as a severe hardship. Bah.

The other thing to keep in mind is really how puny these cuts are. The President, as best we can tell, has agreed to a trillion or two of cuts to his budget, which would bring his ten year spending projection down to $45 trillion and a deficit in 2020 still in excess of $1 trillion.